IPPNY President Gavin Donohue said generators are willing to work with New York regulators regarding the state’s capacity market but said it’s unclear what changes are being sought. “What problem are we trying to solve?” he asked. “We’ve had stresses on the system during the winter [and] during the summer the last few years and quite frankly the system has worked very well.”
IPPNY Chairman John Reese, senior vice president of US Power Generation, called on state regulators to demonstrate “courage” by pushing for an increase in the cost of new entry. “Nobody believes you can actually build or enter the New York market for the current cost of new entry price,” he said. “Upstate New York capacity prices are lower than PJM, are lower than New England. Those are not survivable.”
Kenneth Daly, CEO of National Grid New York, speaks as James Gallagher, executive director of the New York State Smart Grid Consortium (left), and UBS Securities analyst Michael Weinstein (right) listen. Daly said the next five years of the state’s Reforming the Energy Vision initiative will be transitional, as state regulators evaluate demonstration projects and determine which worked and which did not. “Ten years from now is when we’ll start to see game changers. Battery storage is clearly the one biggest change that our industry will face. And if we go through another investment cycle these next five years of modernizing our grids we’ll then have far greater capability in that second five-year period to integrate renewables, to give customers choice, to use more local demand response.”
Richard Dewey, executive vice president of NYISO (left), and John Shelk, president of the Electric Power Supply Association (right), said EPA’s final Clean Power Plan addressed problems with the draft rule. Dewey said the preliminary rule “would have left us with about one to three days of oil burn in New York state – which is about 100 less than we typically need [for] reliability.” Shelk said the final rule fixed an “artificial” advantage for new gas plants. But he said it remains unclear how regions outside the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative will incorporate carbon costs in economic dispatch. “Clearly we’re not going to have — certainly not on day one — a price on carbon in the rest of the states,” he said.
