Arizona regulators approved a demand-side management plan for Arizona Public Service that slashed the plan’s proposed budget by more than half and eliminated many of its programs — but spared and even encouraged virtual power plant programs.
The Arizona Corporation Commission voted 5-0 on Dec. 3 to approve the scaled-back plan with a budget of $40 million rather than the requested $91 million.
ACC staff recommended approval of APS’ DSM plan, finding that the plan’s newly proposed programs would be cost-effective.
But Chair Kevin Thompson proposed an amendment, which the commission approved, that slashed the plan’s programs and budget.
“I’ve been anxious to get this matter before this commission so that we can trim some of the bloat and fat from this budget,” Thompson said.
Thompson blamed the situation on previous commissions that “condoned and even required these programs to expand to the point where they ballooned beyond the intent of the original goals.”
An APS representative said the company didn’t oppose Thompson’s amendment.
ACC rules require utilities to file a DSM plan. The cost of programs in an approved plan can be recovered through a customer fee.
Among programs the commission rejected were APS’ proposed measures to encourage mini-split heat pumps and air conditioners and pool pump recalibrations in existing homes.
The ACC suspended all funding for the residential new construction program, which offered incentives to builders that meet energy efficiency standards in new homes. APS had proposed increasing an incentive, from $100 to $200, for prewiring new homes for EV charging.
Thompson said installing energy efficient appliances in new homes is already required by law.
The ACC axed incentives for electric golf carts, high-frequency golf cart battery chargers and energy-efficient livestock fans. APS said in its plan that golf cart-style utility vehicles are increasingly popular as work vehicles beyond golf courses.
Funding was eliminated for the conservation behavior program, which has provided home energy reports and personalized energy-saving tips to about 500,000 residential customers.
VPP Programs Spared
Spared from the chopping block was a home weatherization program for low-income residents.
The commission also saved APS’ virtual power plant programs, which include commercial and industrial demand response and the Cool Rewards residential program. Cool Rewards gives a $35 annual credit to customers who agree to have their thermostat setting raised when energy demand increases during a summer heat event.
APS wants to expand Cool Rewards beyond its 4 to 7 p.m. timeframe in June through September. Market prices can still be high from 7 to 8 p.m., said Kerri Carnes, director of customer to grid solutions for APS.
“There have been instances where it would have been nice to call on those thermostats in early October, for instance,” Carnes told the commission.
Also spared was a “bring your own device” pilot program for home batteries, which the commission approved in March. APS customers who agree to participate in up to 60 battery-dispatch events from May through October will be compensated with an annual $110/kW capacity payment.
The commission approved an amendment from Vice Chair Nick Myers that directs APS to strengthen its VPP programs.
Myers wants to see APS adopt a “more cohesive” VPP strategy, potentially consolidating separate programs.
“A VPP should not be treated as a niche pilot or a scattered set of incentives,” Myers said. “It should operate as a true grid asset — one capable of delivering firm capacity, supporting reliability events and reducing the pressure on ratepayers to build traditional generation or wires solutions prematurely.”